Tax planning for contingency fee attorneys generally works best before a large fee becomes payable. A fee received in one year may be taxed at higher rates, 401(k)s and IRAs have annual limits, and traditional fee deferral generally postpones tax rather than removing it. The right approach depends on your firm structure, income pattern, and goals.
Key Takeaways
- A large contingency fee is generally taxed in the year it is received or made available to you, so one big case can change a single year's tax picture.
- Federal income tax rates rise in layers as income rises, so a concentrated fee may place more of your income in higher brackets. Other thresholds can also apply.
- 401(k)s, IRAs, and traditional attorney fee deferral can each help in some situations, and each has limits worth understanding before you rely on it.
- Timing matters. Options that depend on how a fee is paid are generally decided before the fee is available to you, which is why early planning with your own advisors is important.
- Nothing here is tax advice. Bring the questions at the end of this guide to your own tax, legal, and financial advisors.
How Are Contingency Fees Taxed When You Receive Them?
In general terms, a contingency fee is income to the attorney or the law firm that earns it. For a taxpayer who reports income on the cash method, the federal rules look at when income is actually received or constructively received. Under the Treasury regulation on constructive receipt, income is generally treated as received in the year it is credited to your account, set apart for you, or otherwise made available so that you can draw on it, unless your control over it is subject to substantial limits or restrictions (26 CFR § 1.451-2).
What that means for a particular fee depends on how your practice is organized, how your firm reports income, and the terms of your fee agreements. Those are questions for your own tax advisor.
Why Can One Large Settlement Year Push Income Into Higher Brackets?
Federal income tax is applied in layers. According to the IRS, as income rises, the tax rate on the next layer of income is higher, and the higher rate applies only to the part of income that falls in the new bracket (IRS: Federal income tax rates and brackets).
For an attorney whose income is irregular, that can matter. A case may take years to resolve, and then a large fee may land in a single tax year. More of that year's income may be taxed at the upper rates than if the same amount had arrived over several years. Depending on your situation, other income-based thresholds, such as phase-outs or additional taxes, may also come into play. The effect varies with filing status, entity structure, state taxes, and your other income.
What Can Conventional Tools Do, and Where Are Their Limits?
Most attorneys start with the tools that are already familiar. Each can be useful, and each has limits.
401(k) and IRA contributions. These may offer tax advantages on money you set aside. The IRS publishes annual limits on contributions, adjusted over time (IRS: 401(k) and profit-sharing plan contribution limits). A large fee may be much bigger than what these plans can absorb in one year. A firm plan may also bring participation requirements for employees, and distribution rules may limit access to the funds. Our FAQs cover why a 401(k) alone may not be enough in a high-fee year.
Traditional attorney fee deferral. A fee deferral arrangement may let you postpone receiving part of a fee, so payments arrive over time instead of in one lump sum. It may help spread taxable income across several years. It also has limits: taxes are generally deferred, not eliminated, future payments are typically taxed as ordinary income, and payment schedules can be hard to change once set. Our complete guide to attorney fee deferral walks through how these arrangements work and where they fall short.
Other deductions and entity-level planning. Your tax advisor may also review business deductions, entity choices, and timing of expenses. These depend heavily on your facts and may not offset a large fee on their own.
Why Does Planning Need to Happen Before a Large Fee Becomes Payable?
Because the constructive receipt rules look at when income is available to you, options that depend on how and when a fee is paid are generally evaluated before the fee is available. Once a fee has been received or made available, some choices may no longer be open.
That is why many attorneys raise these questions when a large case is approaching resolution, not after the check arrives. Exactly when an election or arrangement must be in place relative to a fee depends on your facts and the governing rules, and should be confirmed with your own tax counsel.
Where Does Attorney feeSaver™ Fit?
Some established contingency fee attorneys look beyond traditional fee deferral. Attorney feeSaver™ is designed to go beyond tax deferral for eligible plaintiff attorneys and law firm owners. It combines attorney fee deferral with an executive benefits strategy, and it is intended to pursue effectively tax-free results on qualifying contingency fees, opportunities for tax-free future income (qualifying future distributions that generally are not taxed on receipt when applicable requirements are maintained), and family financial protection.
It is not right for everyone. Eligibility and program requirements apply, outcomes depend on individual circumstances, and individualized illustrations rely on assumptions that may not be realized. The tax treatment of the strategy has not been approved by the IRS. A specialized tax opinion supports the program, and its scope, assumptions, and limitations apply. To see the structure at a high level, visit How It Works. Detailed questions about the underlying structure are addressed in a confidential Attorney feeSaver™ presentation with Joseph DiGangi.
What Are Common Misconceptions About Reducing Taxes as an Attorney?
- "Deferral means the tax goes away." Deferral generally postpones tax to a later year. Future payments may be taxed when received.
- "A maxed-out 401(k) covers a big fee year." Annual contribution limits may leave most of a large fee outside the plan.
- "I can decide after the fee arrives." Some options may be unavailable once a fee is received or made available to you.
- "One strategy fits every attorney." Results depend on firm structure, income, age, health, and goals.
What Questions Should You Take to Your Tax Advisor?
- How are my contingency fees reported under my current entity structure and accounting method?
- If a large fee arrives this year, what would my marginal rates and other thresholds look like, including state taxes?
- How much of that fee could my current retirement plans realistically absorb?
- If I consider fee deferral, when must the arrangement be in place relative to the fee, and what are the risks and limits?
- How would deferred payments be taxed when I receive them, and how could that compare with today?
- What would my plan look like if a few big cases resolve in the same year, or none do?
- Are there approaches that go beyond traditional deferral, and what eligibility requirements, costs, and risks come with them?
- What documentation would I need before a large fee becomes payable?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is tax planning for contingency fee attorneys only about reducing this year's tax bill? Not necessarily. Many attorneys also look at how fees are spread over time, how retirement income may be built, and how family protection fits in. Any approach has trade-offs, and results depend on individual circumstances.
Can I eliminate taxes on a large contingency fee? No approach should be assumed to remove tax. Traditional deferral generally postpones it. Any strategy that aims for a different net outcome carries eligibility requirements and risks, and should be reviewed with your own tax counsel.
When should I start planning for a large fee? Generally before the fee is payable. Waiting until a fee is received may limit the options available.
Next Steps
If a significant fee is on the horizon and you would like to talk through your options, you can take either of two next steps:
- Schedule a confidential consultation with Joseph DiGangi, CFP®, CSSC.
- Request the one-page tax opinion summary if you would like more information before scheduling. The summary is an overview of a specialized tax opinion. It is not IRS approval and does not guarantee any tax treatment.
Sources
- U.S. Treasury, 26 CFR § 1.451-2, Constructive receipt of income (eCFR).
- Internal Revenue Service, Federal income tax rates and brackets.
- Internal Revenue Service, Retirement topics: 401(k) and profit-sharing plan contribution limits.
This article is for general educational purposes only and is not tax, legal, or investment advice. Tax rules change and depend on individual circumstances. Please consult your own tax, legal, and financial advisors before making any decisions.